The Certainty Paradox
v4.1.0by MKCustomDifficulty:
"Open Script Tool" pre-loads this script's characters directly on script.bloodontheclocktower.com, the same way it works from other script libraries.
Characters
Townsfolk
GrandmotherYou start knowing a good player & their character. If the Demon kills them, you die too.
PixieYou start knowing 1 in-play Townsfolk. If you were mad that you were this character, you gain their ability when they die.
High PriestessEach night, learn which player the Storyteller believes you should talk to most.
Village IdiotEach night, choose a player: you learn their alignment. [+0 to +2 Village Idiots. 1 of the extras is drunk]
Town CrierEach night*, you learn if a Minion nominated today.
InnkeeperEach night*, choose 2 players: they can't die tonight, but 1 is drunk until dusk.
GamblerEach night*, choose a player & guess their character: if you guess wrong, you die.
AcrobatEach night*, if either good living neighbour is drunk or poisoned, you die.
LycanthropeEach night*, choose a living player: if good, they die, but they are the only player that can die tonight.
HuntsmanOnce per game, at night, choose a living player: the Damsel, if chosen, becomes a not-in-play Townsfolk. [+the Damsel]
FishermanOnce per game, during the day, visit the Storyteller for some advice to help you win.
Alchemist
You have a not-in-play Minion ability.
Poppy GrowerMinions & Demons do not know each other. If you die, they learn who each other are that night.
Outsider
DrunkYou do not know you are the Drunk. You think you are a Townsfolk character, but you are not.
Plague DoctorWhen you die, the Storyteller gains a Minion ability.
ZealotIf there are 5 or more players alive, you must vote for every nomination.
DamselAll Minions know you are in play. If a Minion publicly guesses you (once), your team loses.
Minion
GodfatherYou start knowing which Outsiders are in play. If 1 died today, choose a player tonight: they die.
HarpyEach night, choose 2 players: tomorrow, the 1st player is mad that the 2nd is evil, or one or both might die.
AssassinOnce per game, at night*, choose a player: they die, even if for some reason they could not.
WizardOnce per game, choose to make a wish. If granted, it might have a price & leave a clue as to its nature.
Organ GrinderAll players keep their eyes closed when voting and the vote tally is secret. Each night, choose if you are drunk until dusk.
Demon
Lil' Monsta
Each night, Minions choose who babysits Lil' Monsta's token & "is the Demon". A player dies each night*. [+1 Minion]
OjoEach night*, choose a character: they die. If they are not in play, the Storyteller chooses who dies.
Traveller
ThiefEach night, choose a player (not yourself): their vote counts negatively tomorrow.
HarlotEach night*, choose a living player: if they agree, you learn their character, but you both might die.
Bone CollectorOnce per game, at night, choose a dead player: they regain their ability until dusk.
JudgeOnce per game, if another player nominated, you may choose to force the current execution to pass or fail.
ApprenticeOn your 1st night, you gain a Townsfolk ability (if good), or a Minion ability (if evil).
Fabled & Loric
DjinnUse the Djinn's special rule. All players know what it is.
Night order
First night
- 1DDusk
Start the Night Phase.
- 2MMinion Info
If there are 7 or more players, wake all Minions: Show the THIS IS THE DEMON token. Point to the Demon. Show THESE ARE YOUR MINIONS token. Point to the other Minions.
- 3DDemon Info
If there are 7 or more players, wake the Demon. Show the Demon token. Show all Minions. Show the THESE CHARACTERS ARE NOT IN PLAY token. Show 3 not-in-play good character tokens.
- 4
AlchemistShow the Alchemist a not-in-play Minion token
- 5
Poppy GrowerDo not inform the Demon/Minions who each other are
- 6
Lil' MonstaWake all Minions together, allow them to vote by pointing at who they want to babysit Lil' Monsta.
- 7
GodfatherShow each of the Outsider tokens in play.
- 8
PixieShow the Pixie 1 in-play Townsfolk character token.
- 9
HuntsmanThe Huntsman shakes their head 'no' or points to a player. If they point to the Damsel, wake that player, show the 'You are' card and a not-in-play character token.
- 10
DamselWake all the Minions, show them the 'This character selected you' card and the Damsel token.
- 11
GrandmotherShow the marked character token. Point to the marked player.
- 12DDawn
Wait for a few seconds. End the Night Phase.
Other nights
- 1DDusk
Start the Night Phase.
- 2
Poppy GrowerIf the Poppy Grower has died, show the Minions/Demon who each other are.
- 3
InnkeeperThe previously protected and drunk players lose those markers. The Innkeeper points to two players. Those players are protected. One is drunk.
- 4
GamblerThe Gambler points to a player, and a character on their sheet. If incorrect, the Gambler dies.
- 5
LycanthropeThe Lycanthrope points to a living player: if good, they die and no one else can die tonight.
- 6
Lil' MonstaWake all Minions together, allow them to vote by pointing at who they want to babysit Lil' Monsta. Choose a player, that player dies.
- 7
AssassinIf the Assassin has not yet used their ability: The Assassin either shows the 'no' head signal, or points to a player. That player dies.
- 8
GodfatherIf an Outsider died today: The Godfather points to a player. That player dies.
- 9
AcrobatIf a good living neighbour is drunk or poisoned, the Acrobat player dies.
- 10
HuntsmanThe Huntsman shakes their head 'no' or points to a player. If they point to the Damsel, wake that player, show the 'You are' card and a not-in-play character token.
- 11
DamselIf selected by the Huntsman, wake the Damsel, show 'You are' card and a not-in-play Townsfolk token.
- 12
GrandmotherIf the Grandmother’s grandchild was killed by the Demon tonight: The Grandmother dies.
- 13
Town CrierNod 'yes' or shake head 'no' for whether a Minion nominated today. Place the 'Minion not nominated' marker (remove 'Minion nominated', if any).
- 14DDawn
Wait for a few seconds. End the Night Phase.
High Priestess, Village Idiot, Plague Doctor, Zealot, Harpy, Wizard, Organ Grinder, Ojo, Djinn don't have night-order data in BOTChub yet — check the printed script or Script Tool for exact placement.
Jinxes

Alchemist & Organ GrinderIf the Alchemist has the Organ Grinder ability, the Organ Grinder is in play. If both are sober, both are drunk.

Lil' Monsta & Poppy GrowerIf Lil' Monsta & the Poppy Grower are alive, Minions wake one by one, until one of them chooses to take the Lil' Monsta token.