Both. Both is Good.
v1.1.0by Zee, Luxray, & JustinCustomDifficulty:
"Open Script Tool" pre-loads this script's characters directly on script.bloodontheclocktower.com, the same way it works from other script libraries.
Characters
Townsfolk
KnightYou start knowing 2 players that are not the Demon.
LibrarianYou start knowing that 1 of 2 players is a particular Outsider. (Or that zero are in play.)
High PriestessEach night, learn which player the Storyteller believes you should talk to most.
SailorEach night, choose an alive player: either you or they are drunk until dusk. You can't die.
Snake CharmerEach night, choose an alive player: a chosen Demon swaps characters & alignments with you & is then poisoned.
KingEach night, if the dead outnumber the living, you learn 1 alive character. The Demon knows who you are.
GamblerEach night*, choose a player & guess their character: if you guess wrong, you die.
GossipEach day, you may make a public statement. Tonight, if it was true, a player dies.
ProfessorOnce per game, at night*, choose a dead player: if they are a Townsfolk, they are resurrected.
FoolThe first time you die, you don't.
Magician
The Demon thinks you are a Minion. Minions think you are a Demon.
ChoirboyIf the Demon kills the King, you learn which player is the Demon. [+ the King]
VirginThe 1st time you are nominated, if the nominator is a Townsfolk, they are executed immediately.
Outsider
ButlerEach night, choose a player (not yourself): tomorrow, you may only vote if they are voting too.
KlutzWhen you learn that you died, publicly choose 1 alive player: if they are evil, your team loses.
DrunkYou do not know you are the Drunk. You think you are a Townsfolk character, but you are not.
LunaticYou think you are a Demon, but you are not. The Demon knows who you are & who you choose at night.
Minion
GodfatherYou start knowing which Outsiders are in play. If 1 died today, choose a player tonight: they die.
Devil's AdvocateEach night, choose a living player (different to last night): if executed tomorrow, they don't die.
SpyEach night, you see the Grimoire. You might register as good & as a Townsfolk or Outsider, even if dead.
Scarlet Woman
If there are 5 or more players alive & the Demon dies, you become the Demon. (Travellers don't count)
Demon
PukkaEach night, choose a player: they are poisoned. The previously poisoned player dies then becomes healthy.
No DashiiEach night*, choose a player: they die. Your 2 Townsfolk neighbours are poisoned.
ShabalothEach night*, choose 2 players: they die. A dead player you chose last night might be regurgitated.
Fang GuEach night*, choose a player: they die. The 1st Outsider this kills becomes an evil Fang Gu & you die instead. [+1 Outsider]
Fabled & Loric
DjinnUse the Djinn's special rule. All players know what it is.
Night order
First night
- 1DDusk
Start the Night Phase.
- 2MMinion Info
If there are 7 or more players, wake all Minions: Show the THIS IS THE DEMON token. Point to the Demon. Show THESE ARE YOUR MINIONS token. Point to the other Minions.
- 3DDemon Info
If there are 7 or more players, wake the Demon. Show the Demon token. Show all Minions. Show the THESE CHARACTERS ARE NOT IN PLAY token. Show 3 not-in-play good character tokens.
- 4
Magician - 5
LunaticIf 7 or more players: Show the Lunatic a number of arbitrary 'Minions', players equal to the number of Minions in play. Show 3 character tokens of arbitrary good characters. If the token received by the Lunatic is a Demon that would wake tonight: Allow the Lunatic to do the Demon actions. Place their 'attack' markers. Wake the Demon. Show the Demon’s real character token. Show them the Lunatic player. If the Lunatic attacked players: Show the real demon each marked player. Remove any Lunatic 'attack' markers.
- 6
KingWake the Demon, show them the 'This character selected you' card, show the King token and point to the King player.
- 7
SailorThe Sailor points to a living player. Either the Sailor, or the chosen player, is drunk.
- 8
Snake CharmerThe Snake Charmer points to a player. If that player is the Demon: swap the Demon and Snake Charmer character and alignments. Wake each player to inform them of their new role and alignment. The new Snake Charmer is poisoned.
- 9
GodfatherShow each of the Outsider tokens in play.
- 10
Devil's AdvocateThe Devil’s Advocate points to a living player. That player survives execution tomorrow.
- 11
PukkaThe Pukka points to a player. That player is poisoned.
- 12
LibrarianShow the character token of an Outsider in play. Point to two players, one of which is that character.
- 13
ButlerThe Butler points to a player. Mark that player as 'Master'.
- 14
SpyShow the Grimoire to the Spy for as long as they need.
- 15DDawn
Wait for a few seconds. End the Night Phase.
Other nights
- 1DDusk
Start the Night Phase.
- 2
SailorThe previously drunk player is no longer drunk. The Sailor points to a living player. Either the Sailor, or the chosen player, is drunk.
- 3
GamblerThe Gambler points to a player, and a character on their sheet. If incorrect, the Gambler dies.
- 4
Snake CharmerThe Snake Charmer points to a player. If that player is the Demon: swap the Demon and Snake Charmer character and alignments. Wake each player to inform them of their new role and alignment. The new Snake Charmer is poisoned.
- 5
Devil's AdvocateThe Devil’s Advocate points to a living player, different from the previous night. That player survives execution tomorrow.
- 6
Scarlet WomanIf the Scarlet Woman became the Demon today: Show the 'You are' card, then the demon token.
- 7
LunaticAllow the Lunatic to do the actions of the Demon. Place their 'attack' markers. If the Lunatic selected players: Wake the Demon. Show the 'attack' marker, then point to each marked player. Remove any Lunatic 'attack' markers.
- 8
PukkaThe Pukka points to a player. That player is poisoned. The previously poisoned player dies.
- 9
ShabalothOne player that the Shabaloth chose the previous night might be resurrected. The Shabaloth points to two players. Those players die.
- 10
Fang GuThe Fang Gu points to a player. That player dies. Or, if that player was an Outsider and there are no other Fang Gu in play: The Fang Gu dies instead of the chosen player. The chosen player is now an evil Fang Gu. Wake the new Fang Gu. Show the 'You are' card, then the Fang Gu token. Show the 'You are' card, then the thumb-down 'evil' hand sign.
- 11
No DashiiThe No Dashii points to a player. That player dies.
- 12
GodfatherIf an Outsider died today: The Godfather points to a player. That player dies.
- 13
GossipIf the Gossip’s public statement was true: Choose a player not protected from dying tonight. That player dies.
- 14
ProfessorIf the Professor has not used their ability: The Professor either shakes their head no, or points to a player. If that player is a Townsfolk, they are now alive.
- 15
ChoirboyIf the King was killed by the Demon, wake the Choirboy and point to the Demon player.
- 16
KingIf there are more dead than living, show the King a character token of a living player.
- 17
ButlerThe Butler points to a player. Mark that player as 'Master'.
- 18
SpyShow the Grimoire to the Spy for as long as they need.
- 19DDawn
Wait for a few seconds. End the Night Phase.
Knight, High Priestess, Djinn don't have night-order data in BOTChub yet — check the printed script or Script Tool for exact placement.
Jinxes

Magician & SpyWhen the Spy sees the Grimoire, the Demon and Magician's character tokens are removed.

Scarlet Woman & Fang GuIf there would be two Demons, one of which was the Scarlet Woman, the Scarlet Woman remains the Scarlet Woman.